In contemplating the regular turbulence our healthcare system experiences, Seamus Heaney’s wonderful poem ‘Postcript’ came to mind, writes Denis Doherty.
Inspired by his experience of travelling along what he called the ‘Flaggy shore of Clare’ in a storm in the company of his wife and Brian Friel and his wife he came to this conclusion,

“Useless to think you’ll park and capture it,
More thoroughly. You are neither here nor there,
A hurry through which known and strange things pass,
As big soft buffetings come at the car sideways
And catch the heart off guard and blow it open”
Having parked the car and attempted to capture it, I can vouch for the wisdom of his advice. Those who, since 1970 have planned, funded, managed and delivered our health services will, I suspect, empathise with it also.
Healthcare systems tend to be very different, making comparisons difficult. Total cost comparisons are of some value but outcomes comparisons and value for money considerations are more difficult. Media coverage tends to favour the faults, failures and weaknesses aspects of a service that is constantly evolving. Technological developments have contributed greatly to healthcare improvements and who knows what role AI will play in the not too distant future? A focus on the development of AI diagnostic, treatment and care modalities appear to have great potential.
Healthcare capital projects will surely benefit from AI. The recent experience, not just here but also in the UK have produced many examples of poor practice. The National Children’s Hospital is an example of how not to manage a project of the size and complexity of that hospital. Having taken years to agree where to locate the hospital it has now taken, it seems, many years longer than would be reasonable to complete a project of the scale and complexity involved. The end is still out of sight. Perish the thought that developments in paediatric hospital care since the hospital was designed may seriously reduce the fitness for purpose of the new hospital.
Our Children’s Hospital is not the only new hospital that has experienced serious problems. Examples of problems close to home are easy to find.
A new maternity hospital in Belfast remains unopened. It is alleged to be tens of millions over budget and a decade behind schedule. A timescale for the opening of the hospital has not been announced.
In Glasgow, Scottish government ministers have denied knowledge of water and ventilation problems at Scotland’s largest new hospital before it opened. A very costly inquiry has heard that deaths and high levels of infection gave rise to concern.
The discovery of poor practice is not confined to just major capital projects. Medical records deserve to be treated with respect. Yet, very recently the disregard for historical medical records in Ireland was highlighted as a result of large volumes of medical records being discovered in disused buildings having been, it would appear, dumped there. That discovery did not seem to prompt questions regarding the disregard in which our medical records are held.
In Scotland, the Public Services Ombudsman has questioned the accuracy of medical records there. Here, that issue does not appear to have been raised. The reality is that we may not be in a fit state to provide information on our medical history when most needed. In the digital age, surely we should be interested in our medical history being accessible to those who treat us in times of health crises? That, of course, risks exposing our medical notes in the event of a cyber attack. It can be argued that files dumped in a disused building carry an even greater risk.
It doesn’t have to remain the way it is. I have in the past written in praise of the new University Hospital in Arhus, the largest hospital project in Denmark. That hospital recently selected the technology needed to enable it to achieve its aim to be a fiber based hospital of the future.
Our hospitals are doing outstanding work that does not receive the recognition their successes deserve. It beholds the HSE and indeed our hospitals to accentuate the positive. It is in our nature to respond better to praise than to criticism.
That said, criticism is appropriate where it is justified. The term insourcing in our health services was unheard of until recently or at least not in the context it was used in our service. The term came to mean employees forming companies for the purpose of selling the services of existing employees to their employers during their off duty time. Why not settle for old style paid overtime? The problem was compounded when it emerged that some consultants engaged in public practice were receiving private fees or gifts for caring for private patients. The problem of the misbehavior of the few sets a bad example to medical and other colleagues playing by the rules.
These and other issues such as overreliance on agency staff, the use of unapproved devices in paediatric surgery by one Consultant and a general impression that the HSE is not amenable to financial control are undermining staff morale. There are concerns that recruitment practices, staff development, promotion practices and so on are not always fit for purpose, Very many staff within the HSE feel beleaguered and undervalued. It is much easier and less costly to recruit well and facilitate the personal and professional development of staff than to develop reliance on agency staff.
There has been post budget discussion on the issue of the disconnect between the amount of funds being provided and the cost of providing the level of service the HSE is expected to provide and the measures necessary to function within budget. The HSE attracts a lot of criticism for overspending but in the absence of information in relation to the level of service expected of it and the level of funding allocated to it, the HSE may be the victim of underfunding. Evidence of the adequacy of the funding allocated to the HSE and the cost of the level of service it needed to provide would be helpful in forming a fair judgment on the performance of the service providers. It seems that some large and vitally necessary non-statutory service providers, voluntary public hospitals for example, are carrying sizeable financial deficits. It is surely in the interests of the debtors and the taxpayers that issues of that nature are resolved. That said, if media reports on how department budgets are determined are accurate, they sometimes appear to resemble the Ballinasloe Horse Fair model of dealing and we may have to await fit for purpose AI based budgeting and financial control.
In the meantime nature and the Atlantic Ocean will continue to provide magical displays in storms along the Flaggy Shore of Clare in the months of September and October.

